I am currently writing “A Suite of Bagatelles” for solo piano; ultimately there will be six. I am in the process examining my own musical language. Though it may sound paradoxical, with this set of short piano pieces I am also working on the challenge of effective large-scale planning. In the process I have been playing and studying the bagatelles of Beethoven and Bartók and a number of other short keyboard pieces, notably of Couperin, Rameau, Schumann and Debussy.

The history of the use of the title, “Bagatelle” is fascinating and this history is important to my own process. I have immersed myself in the past few months (not for the first time) in the playing of and study of the most important bagatelles for piano, those of Ludwig Van Beethoven and of Béla Bartók. These pieces are each only several minutes long, but in the case of both composers each piece presents a new problem and solves it in a definitive way. They are not easy to understand and interpret well, largely because they are short but are not “miniature” or in any way trivial; formally and expressively they are in a real sense “big”.

Bartók and Beethoven in very distinct idioms separated by a century of radical change in the language of Western classical music, have worked out problems for themselves in form and expression. In my own modest way, I am trying to emulate them.

The word bagatelle means literally “a trifle” but like so many aspects of European concert music it’s use was transformed and redefined by Beethoven. François Couperin did use the title for a short piece for two manual harpsichord in the baroque era but that work is not really very different from his many brief and often quite astounding and often humorous keyboard works. Couperin’s “Les Bagatelles” are a bit trifling. But Beethoven by his use of the term for his short, but very finished piano pieces, defined the use of the expression for us.

Beethoven wrote bagatelles for piano throughout his career and published three collections of them. He took them seriously but not everyone else has; neither his contemporaries nor many musicians since. The “Eleven New Bagatelles”, Opus 119, include several extremely short pieces. Number 10, the penultimate of the collection, contains one eight bar phrase which is repeated and its second ending is followed by a four bar coda. The tempo is not slow so the whole piece lasts about half a minute. But it sounds complete, is written in the language of the time and is masterfully Beethovenian. It does in a sense link number 9 and number 11 but it can stand on its own; it is not a fragment.